Sunday, December 8, 2013


by Jenna Black

Reviewed by Sesana
Three out of five stars

Publisher Summary:

Dana Hathaway doesn't know it yet, but she's in big trouble. When her alcoholic mom shows up at her voice recital drunk, again, Dana decides she's had enough and runs away to find her mysterious father in Avalon: the only place on Earth where the regular, everyday world and the captivating, magical world of Faerie intersect. But from the moment Dana sets foot in Avalon, everything goes wrong, for it turns out she isn't just an ordinary teenage girl, she's a Faeriewalker, a rare individual who can travel between both worlds, and the only person who can bring magic into the human world and technology into Faerie.

Dana finds herself tangled up in a cutthroat game of Fae politics. Someone's trying to kill her, and everyone seems to want something from her, from her newfound friends and family to Ethan, the hot Fae guy Dana figures she'll never have a chance with...until she does. Caught between two worlds, Dana isn't sure where she'll ever fit in and who can be trusted, not to mention if her world will ever be normal again.

My Review:

 I'm cutting Glimmerglass a bit of a break here, because it was readable. Even though Black's writing wasn't the best in the world, she at least kept me engaged through much of the book. And I did get Dana, for the most part. Sure, jetting to another country (another realm, really) to meet the father that she'd never known wasn't the smartest choice. But who's been teaching Dana how to make smart choices? Not her alcoholic mother. And I could understand her feeling fed up and just wanting to get away. Her reactions to the newness of Avalon, a city that's part fairy and part human, rang true to me.

But I did get frustrated with some of Dana's shallower moments. She got so distracted, so easily by any cute guy, and is willing to forgive a lot for a charming smile that she knows might not be sincere. Just the thought of the love triangle that will probably be in future books is enough to keep me away.

And the writing... Not exactly accomplished. And it makes Dana sound even more immature than I think she's meant to be. There's a moment, late in the book, when Dana has nearly drowned. Naturally, she inhales some water, and naturally, she has to hack it back up again. Her reaction? "Ewww, gross!" Really? This is your thought upon nearly drowning, that coughing up water is kind of icky? It wasn't the only time that Dana's internal narration went for an oddly inappropriate line, or struck a tone that was greatly at odds with her personality in other situations. And it dragged the book down quite a bit, to have tense moments interrupted with something that just didn't gel.

I probably won't be reading further. I wasn't engaged enough with the characters, the romance, or the setting to want to continue. There are some great ideas in here, though, which is almost enough to make me want to see if Black's writing improves. Almost.

No comments:

Post a Comment