Friday, March 21, 2014

The Knife of Never Letting Go

Patrick Ness
Walker Books Ltd.
Reviewed by: Nancy
3 out of 5 stars


Prentisstown isn't like other towns. Everyone can hear everyone else's thoughts in an overwhelming, never-ending stream of Noise. Just a month away from the birthday that will make him a man, Todd and his dog, Manchee -- whose thoughts Todd can hear too, whether he wants to or not -- stumble upon an area of complete silence. They find that in a town where privacy is impossible, something terrible has been hidden -- a secret so awful that Todd and Manchee must run for their lives.

My Review
Young Todd Hewitt is on the verge of manhood and living in Prentisstown, a world without women and where the thoughts of men and “creachers” can be heard.  Todd’s dad died of illness and his ma was the “last of the women”, according to Ben, one of two men who are raising him.  Todd likes to go to the swamp to collect apples, because it is the only place where he can get a break from men’s “Noise” – their secrets, their thoughts, their memories.  While out on a walk with his talking dog, Manchee, Todd encounters a break in the Noise, a pocket of silence.  When Todd and Manchee return home, their Noise reveals what happened in the swamp, and Todd, with Manchee, a packed bag, Ben’s big hunting knife, and his mom’s journal, is sent away from the only home he’s ever known. 

When Todd encounters a girl on his travels, and comes across towns filled with men and women, everything he’s ever known about the world is changed in an instant.  The men of Prentisstown are harboring a terrible secret and will stop at nothing to get Todd back. 

I really wanted to love this story.  It won several major literary awards, including the 2008 Tiptree Award, and a few of my Goodreads friends enjoyed it.  I had reservations about reading this, because it is the first in a series and I knew it had a cliffhanger ending. 

It wasn’t a bad book.  It took me just a few pages to get used to Todd’s language that reveals his innocence and lack of education.  At the same time, he is a very well-developed character, with strong sensibilities, hope, and a will to survive.  From the start, Viola and Todd are bonded together in a quest for freedom and survival.  There is no romance, for which I am thankful.  Since Viola doesn’t have any Noise, she is shrouded in silence.  It takes a little longer for Todd to get to know her, but he eventually does and is able to read her thoughts.   The development of Todd’s and Viola’s relationship is my favorite part of this story.  One thing I am bothered about is there was no mention at all of Ben’s and Cillian’s relationship.  Were they roommates, best friends, lovers?  Why was the nature of their relationship kept a secret, while everyone else’s thoughts were laid open?  Since they were such a significant part of Todd’s life, I would have liked to know more.  

The Knife of Never Letting Go was fast-paced, dark, and compelling.  I liked the plot, the suspense, the world, and the concept of hearing every man’s thoughts while women’s are much more difficult to read.  I would have liked more well-developed secondary characters and less chase scenes.   The story engaged my emotions, made my heart race, and left me exhausted.  It also left me feeling vaguely empty and unsatisfied.  I knew about the cliffhanger at the end, but nearly every chapter had a cliffhanger as well.   At times I felt I was watching a TV show instead of reading a book.  And I won’t even talk about Aaron, the charismatic preacher of Prentisstown, who was one of the most one-dimensional characters I’ve ever encountered in YA fiction. 

Also posted at Goodreads